Data Consistency in Multi-Region Deployments#

When you replicate data across regions, you are forced to choose between consistency, latency, and availability. You cannot have all three. Every multi-region system makes this tradeoff explicitly or, more dangerously, implicitly by ignoring it until production exposes the consequences.

The Fundamental Tension#

Strong consistency means every read sees the most recent write, regardless of which region it comes from. This requires cross-region coordination on every write (30-100ms per round trip). Eventual consistency means reads might see stale data, but replicas converge given enough time – usually milliseconds to seconds, but during partitions it can be minutes.

What Active-Active Actually Means#

Active-active means both (or all) regions are serving production traffic simultaneously. Not standing by. Not warmed up and waiting. Actually processing real user requests right now. A user in Frankfurt hits the EU region; a user in Virginia hits the US-East region. Both regions are authoritative. Both can read and write.

This is fundamentally different from active-passive, where the secondary region exists but does not serve traffic until failover. The distinction matters because active-active introduces a class of problems that active-passive avoids entirely – primarily, what happens when two regions modify the same data at the same time.