Secrets Management Decision Framework: From POC to Production

The Secret Zero Problem#

Every secrets management system has the same fundamental challenge: you need a secret to access your secrets. Your Vault token is itself a secret. Your AWS credentials for SSM Parameter Store are themselves secrets. This is the “secret zero” problem – there is always one secret that must be bootstrapped outside the system.

Understanding this helps you make pragmatic choices. No tool eliminates all risk. The goal is to reduce the blast radius and make rotation possible.

Secret Management Patterns

The Problem with Environment Variables#

Environment variables are the most common way to pass secrets to applications. Every framework supports them and they require zero dependencies. They are also the least secure option. Any process running as the same user can read them via /proc/<pid>/environ on Linux. Crash dumps include the full environment. Child processes inherit all variables by default.

# Anyone with host access can read another process's environment
cat /proc/$(pgrep myapp)/environ | tr '\0' '\n' | grep DB_PASSWORD

Environment variables are acceptable for local development. For production secrets, use one of the patterns below.