Testing Strategies in CI Pipelines: A Decision Framework

Testing Strategies in CI Pipelines#

Every CI pipeline faces the same tension: run enough tests to catch bugs before they merge, but not so many that developers wait twenty minutes for feedback on a one-line change. The answer is not running everything everywhere. It is running the right tests at the right time.

The Three Test Tiers#

Tests divide into three tiers based on execution speed, failure signal quality, and infrastructure requirements.

Testing Strategy Selection: Unit, Integration, E2E, and Beyond

Testing Strategy Selection#

Choosing the right mix of tests determines whether your test suite catches real bugs or just consumes CI minutes. There is no single correct answer – the right strategy depends on your system architecture, team size, deployment cadence, and the cost of production failures.

The Testing Pyramid#

The classic testing pyramid, introduced by Mike Cohn, prescribes many unit tests at the base, fewer integration tests in the middle, and a small number of end-to-end tests at the top.